Direct vs Regular Plan Calculator
A regular plan's expense ratio includes a distributor's commission, so it is higher than the direct plan of the same fund. See what the gap adds up to.
Find both on the fund's factsheet.
- Estimated value, lower-cost plan
- ₹48.11 lakh
- Estimated value, higher-cost plan
- ₹43.78 lakh
- Extra cost of the higher-cost plan
- ₹4.33 lakh
Over 15 years on ₹18.00 lakh invested, that is 9.0% of the lower-cost plan's value. A negative figure means the second plan costs less.
- Lower-cost plan
- Higher-cost plan
Year-by-year numbers
| Year | Lower-cost plan | Higher-cost plan | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ₹1,27,744 | ₹1,27,049 | ₹695 |
| 2 | ₹2,70,978 | ₹2,68,099 | ₹2,879 |
| 3 | ₹4,31,581 | ₹4,24,693 | ₹6,888 |
| 4 | ₹6,11,658 | ₹5,98,545 | ₹13,114 |
| 5 | ₹8,13,572 | ₹7,91,555 | ₹22,016 |
| 6 | ₹10,39,969 | ₹10,05,836 | ₹34,133 |
| 7 | ₹12,93,819 | ₹12,43,732 | ₹50,087 |
| 8 | ₹15,78,451 | ₹15,07,844 | ₹70,607 |
| 9 | ₹18,97,596 | ₹18,01,062 | ₹96,534 |
| 10 | ₹22,55,442 | ₹21,26,594 | ₹1,28,847 |
| 11 | ₹26,56,679 | ₹24,88,001 | ₹1,68,678 |
| 12 | ₹31,06,570 | ₹28,89,236 | ₹2,17,334 |
| 13 | ₹36,11,015 | ₹33,34,689 | ₹2,76,326 |
| 14 | ₹41,76,628 | ₹38,29,232 | ₹3,47,396 |
| 15 | ₹48,10,828 | ₹43,78,276 | ₹4,32,552 |
For illustration only, not a recommendation or personal advice. Returns are not guaranteed, and the results depend entirely on the numbers you enter. Investments in securities markets, including stocks and mutual funds, are subject to market risks. Read all related documents carefully before investing.
How it’s calculated
Both plans own the same portfolio, so they earn the same before costs. Each grows at the before-cost return less its own expense ratio. The extra cost is the difference between the two end values.
Plan return ≈ return before costs − that plan's expense ratio Extra cost = value (lower-cost plan) − value (higher-cost plan) Values use the SIP and lumpsum formulas of the other calculators
Assumptions and limits
- Both plans earn the same return before costs, which is true for plans of the same scheme, since they hold one portfolio.
- The expense ratios stay fixed for the whole period; in practice they change over time.
- This is about cost only. A regular plan may come with a distributor's help; the calculator does not value that. Taxes and exit loads are not included.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the regular plan's expense ratio higher?
It includes a commission paid to the distributor or platform that sold it. A direct plan has no such commission, so its expense ratio is lower.
Where do I find the two ratios?
On the fund's factsheet, which lists the expense ratio for both the regular and the direct plan, or on the fund house's website.
Do the two plans have the same portfolio?
Yes. They are two ways to hold the same scheme, with the same manager and holdings. Only the expense ratio, and so the NAV, differs.
Can I switch from a regular to a direct plan?
You can redeem the regular plan and invest in the direct plan. The redemption is a sale, so tax on any gain and any exit load can apply. Check this before switching.
Is the result a recommendation?
No. It shows an arithmetic cost for the numbers you enter, not advice on what to hold.
Reviewed by Rachit Tripathi, Principal Officer, Blacklitt Technologies Private Limited (SEBI Registered Investment Adviser, INA000022428). Last reviewed .
For illustration only, not a recommendation or personal advice. Returns are not guaranteed, and the results depend entirely on the numbers you enter. Investments in securities markets, including stocks and mutual funds, are subject to market risks. Read all related documents carefully before investing.
